Best NFL Quarterbacks

Every visitor's ranking shapes the community order. Sign in to see how yours would line up — who you agree with on this list, and where you'd push back.

Tom Brady is locked at the top. Joe Montana and Patrick Mahomes hold the next two spots with rare agreement across the community.

Only 2 rankers so far. The current top is Tom Brady, but with this few rankings everything is still very much in motion.

#4

Dan Marino

vs.

Peyton Manning

#5

Peyton Manning

Dan Marino at #4 and Peyton Manning at #5 are essentially tied. One more ranking could flip the order.

2 rankers in, with 11 items in the running. Early picks like Tom Brady, Joe Montana, Patrick Mahomes are the leaders so far, but the order isn't locked yet.