Not ranked yet
The items are in their starting order, not a ranking. Tiers open once someone has ranked this list.
About this list
Every Pokémon starter trio gets ranked here, from Kanto's Bulbasaur, Charmander, and Squirtle in 1996 through Paldea's Meowscarada, Skeledirge, and Quaquaval in 2022. Entries are judged as complete three-line sets rather than by a single standout, weighing final-stage design, typing, and how the evolutions performed in singles and doubles play. The trios at the top pair three finals fans actually raise with at least one form that reshaped a competitive metagame, instead of leaning on one breakout star.
How the opening order was chosen
The opening order comes from one seed ballot, which sorts the items by one measure: “Trio-wide design consistency weighed against competitive impact of the finals.” A seed ballot is not a person, so this list does not count as ranked until someone ranks it. After that, the seed counts as one ballot beside theirs, no more, and every ballot moves the ranking.
A fair ordering asks whether all three lines hold up, not whether one carried the generation. That splits the top: Kalos and Galar produced starters strong enough to be banned from Smogon's OU tier, while Johto and Kanto offer evener trios with less competitive weight. Whether one Greninja outweighs three solid finals is the argument the top spots turn on.











